Federal Decision on ACORN Funding: Does ACORN Have a Right to Your Tax Dollars??
Patterico:
News broke a couple of days ago that a federal judge had ruled that Congress violated the Constitution when it passed a bill cutting off ACORN’s funding. Specifically, the judge ruled in her opinion that the Congressional act had violated the Bill of Attainder Clause.
I don’t find the decision convincing. It seems to me that the opinion essentially establishes some sort of ongoing right to federal funding. This isn’t like a case where the Government actually punishes someone — such as the hypothetical Eugene Volokh Execution Act of 2009 mentioned in this 2009 Eugene Volokh post on the subject. Congress is simply saying: we choose not to fund a particular organization. Such decisions, it seems to me, are for Congress to make, and not some federal judge.
[…]
1 Comment
Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.
-
Recent
-
Links
- WordPress.com
- WordPress.org
- Site Meter
- EZRA LEVANT
- five feet of fury
- SMALL DEAD ANIMALS
- THE VIEW FROM 1776
- JACK'S NEWSWATCH
- ANGRY IN THE GREAT WHITE NORTH
- MELANIE PHILLIPS
- HOT AIR
- MICHELLE MALKIN
- ANN COULTER
- INSTAPUNDIT
- REAL CLEAR POLITICS
- NRO
- FRONTPAGE MAGAZINE
- THE AMERICAN THINKER
- DISSECTING LEFTISM
- DISCOVERY INSTITUTE
- WND
- THE DAILY TELEGRAPH [UK]
- DRUDGE
- LIFESITENEWS
- NATIONAL POST
- EYE on the UN
- THE JERUSALEM POST
- MACLEANS
- CANADA FREE PRESS
- MARK STEYN
- JIHAD WATCH
- THE SHOTGUN
- BOURQUE
- ONE NEWS NOW
- DAVID WARREN
- THRO' A GLASS DARKLY
- COUNTERTERRORISM BLOG
- BREAKPOINT
- VOICE OF THE MARTYRS
- VICTOR DAVIS HANSON
- FOX NEWS
- ACCURACY IN MEDIA
- PROUD TO BE CANADIAN
- GATES OF VIENNA
- EVOLUTION NEWS AND VIEWS
- TOWNHALL
- FREE DOMINION
- Joel C. Rosenberg
- Alberta Pro-Life
- BIG BLUE WAVE
- No Apologies
- Occidental Soapbox
- Freedom Quest International
- Tea and Politics
- Pro-Life Blogs
- VOM Persecution Blog
- IranAware
- ATLAS SHRUGS
-
Archives
- December 2016 (3)
- November 2016 (21)
- October 2016 (17)
- September 2016 (23)
- August 2016 (23)
- July 2016 (160)
- June 2016 (113)
- May 2016 (177)
- April 2016 (163)
- March 2016 (115)
- February 2016 (172)
- January 2016 (681)
-
Categories
-
RSS
Entries RSS
Comments RSS
Good discussion about this here:
http://federalistblog.us/2010/03/acorn_bill_of_attainder.html
“So was ACORN’s defunding an act of attainder? The answer is clearly no because there was no bill of attainder that stated the accused is hereby convicted, attainted and “shall suffer the pains of death.” Same general arguments with a bill of pains as there was never any bill calling for congressional conviction through enactment. “
Comment by Grant | March 17, 2010